Can’t Decide Whether to Sell or Rent Out Your Home? Read This First.

Thinking about keeping your home as a rental? Or selling it and cashing out? Realtor Katie Roberts shares the key questions to ask when deciding whether to sell or rent out your home in Ohio — plus how to make the smartest move for your future.

You're getting ready to move — maybe into a new house, a new city, or just into a new chapter. But you're stuck on one big question:

Should I sell my current home… or rent it out?

It's not a simple yes or no decision — both options can be smart, depending on your goals, finances, and timeline.

As both a licensed Realtor and experienced property manager in the Centerville and Dayton area, Katie Roberts helps homeowners make this decision with confidence — not confusion.

Here's how to think it through.


When Selling Might Be the Right Move

Selling is often the best choice when:

  • You want access to your equity for your next purchase
  • The market is hot, and you're likely to get top dollar
  • You don't want the responsibility of being a landlord
  • You're moving out of state or don't plan to return
  • Your home needs work and you'd rather not invest more into it

Katie keeps a close eye on local market trends and can give you a realistic, data-driven estimate of what your home could sell for — and how quickly it might sell.


When Renting Could Be a Smart Strategy

Turning your home into a rental can make sense if:

  • You have low mortgage costs and can generate positive cash flow
  • You want to build long-term wealth and passive income
  • You plan to move back in the future
  • You want to wait for home values to appreciate further
  • You're emotionally attached but not ready to say goodbye

Katie works with both seasoned investors and first-time landlords. As a property manager, she can help you find great tenantshandle maintenance, and protect your investment — all without the stress of DIY landlording.


Key Questions to Ask Before You Decide

Still on the fence? Consider these important questions:

  • What's your current mortgage balance?
  • What could your home realistically sell for right now?
  • How much rent could your property bring in?
  • Are you comfortable with tenant turnover, repairs, and property taxes?
  • Do you need your equity to buy your next home?

Katie often runs these numbers side-by-side with her clients — so they can make the best decision not just for today, but for their future.


Can You List It… and Rent It Later?

Absolutely. Some homeowners start by listing their home for sale, then switch to renting if the timing or offers aren't ideal.

Katie helps clients stay flexible:

  • Listing your home while preparing it as a potential rental
  • Tracking interest from both buyers and renters
  • Adjusting your strategy based on real-time market feedback

It's not an either-or decision — with the right support, you can adapt your strategy based on what makes the most financial sense.


Let's Talk Through Your Options — No Pressure

You don't have to guess your way through this. Whether you're leaning toward selling, considering renting, or unsure where to begin, Katie Roberts can help you weigh both paths clearly.

Every home — and homeowner — is different. Let's have a conversation about what's right for you.

Reach out to schedule a personal strategy session and explore your options with someone who knows both sides of the business. When you're ready to move forward, Katie will help you do it the smart way.